National

Aadhaar card alone not valid proof of date of birth, Delhi High Court rules

· 2 sources · Bihar edition

This story has no audio yet

The Delhi High Court has ruled that an Aadhaar card cannot by itself serve as proof of a person's date of birth. Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri delivered the judgment on November 13, in a petition arising from a dispute over the birth date of a female worker whom the employer allegedly terminated in 2017.

The employer argued that she had reached the mandatory retirement age of 58, based on an Aadhaar card showing a birth date of May 20, 1959. The worker said Employees' State Insurance Corporation records gave her birth year as 1960. The court found no independent document backed the Aadhaar date, which the employer had obtained only two months before terminating her. It relied on a 2018 UIDAI memorandum stating that Aadhaar recognises the number only as proof of identity.

The court held that the ESIC record established her birth date as May 20, 1960, so the employer could not use a conflicting Aadhaar date to retire her a year early. It dismissed the employer's challenge to the labour court's ruling, which had found the termination illegal because the Industrial Disputes Act had not been followed.

Key points

  • The Delhi High Court held that an Aadhaar card is not, by itself, proof of date of birth.
  • The employer relied on an Aadhaar date of May 20, 1959 to claim the worker had reached the retirement age of 58.
  • The worker's ESIC records showed a 1960 birth year, and the court accepted that record.
  • The court upheld a labour court ruling that the 2017 termination was unlawful and dismissed the employer's petition.

Coverage from

Topics

This story was put together automatically from the sources above. Open a source to read its original report. How nuze makes stories