Politics

Developing

Columnist says spectacle of faith in India distracts from governance

· 1 source · Bihar edition

This story has no audio yet

The column in Economic Times India argues that spirituality in India is often staged as a spectacle that keeps people from governance issues. The writer recalls anthropologist Clifford Geertz's account of nineteenth-century Bali, where royal ceremony filled the stage while farmers' associations ran the irrigation. Romans, the writer adds, had gladiator games for the same purpose.

In South Indian temples, the writer says, a fixed stone image stays in the sanctum while a portable bronze is paraded on festival days, letting excluded people see a god they could not approach. The same pattern, the writer argues, applies to politics: a garlanded leader is the bronze, while bureaucrats, contractors and financiers, like the unmoving deity, control the real power and money.

Before elections, the writer says, Indian screens fill with pilgrimages, temple inaugurations and films about gods, while jobs, roads and hospitals go unmentioned. The writer argues the spectacle is meant to make people feel all is well. Geertz's Bali had pomp for its own sake, the writer argues, but in India pomp serves power, and power serves capital.

Key points

  • The writer argues that spiritual spectacle in India draws attention away from jobs, healthcare and other governance issues.
  • Using Geertz's study of Bali, the writer says ceremony can mask where the real work and power lie.
  • The writer compares a garlanded political leader to the portable bronze image used in South Indian temple festivals.
  • Bureaucrats, contractors and financiers are described as the unseen machinery that holds real power and money.
  • The writer concludes that in India pomp serves power and power serves capital.

Coverage from

Topics

This story was put together automatically from the sources above. Open a source to read its original report. How nuze makes stories