National

Marriage alone does not qualify woman for Bihar SC quota, Patna High Court rules

· 2 sources · Bihar edition

This story has no audio yet

A division bench of the Patna High Court, headed by Chief Justice V. Kameshwar Rao, dismissed a Letters Patent Appeal filed by Vidyavati Kiran and upheld the earlier order of a single judge. The court said that marrying into Bihar and living there for a long time does not by itself entitle a woman to Scheduled Caste reservation in the state. Reservation depends on the caste's origin in the state and prescribed eligibility conditions.

The case concerns a Bihar Public Service Commission recruitment for assistant public prosecutor posts, advertised on 6 February 2020. Reports say Kiran's father is a permanent resident of Uttar Pradesh, while she married in Bihar in 1996 and has lived there since. She applied under the Dusadh caste as a Scheduled Caste candidate and cleared the preliminary and main examinations, and attended the interview. The final result, issued on 2 December 2023, cancelled her selection.

The commission said her caste and residence certificates had been issued on her husband's address, whereas the rules required them to be based on her father's domicile. The court referred to the Supreme Court's Bir Singh versus Delhi Jal Board case and held that civil domicile acquired through marriage does not automatically confer reservation rights. It also said candidates must follow the rules of a selection process once it has begun and cannot challenge those conditions later at their convenience.

Key points

  • The Patna High Court division bench dismissed the appeal and upheld the single judge's order.
  • The court held that marriage and long residence do not automatically give a woman from another state SC reservation in Bihar.
  • The commission said her certificates were based on her husband's address, while the rules require her father's domicile.
  • The court said candidates must follow selection rules once the process begins and cannot challenge them later.

Coverage from

Topics

This story was put together automatically from the sources above. Open a source to read its original report. How nuze makes stories