National
Mumbai commission dismisses complaint against Tata Motors over Indigo XL defects
The South Mumbai District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission has dismissed a complaint by a Borivali resident against Tata Motors Ltd and its dealer, Wasan Motors Ltd. The commission held that evidence did not conclusively establish a manufacturing defect or deficiency in service, and rejected his demand for a replacement or refund.
Pawar, the complainant, said he bought the car new from Wasan Motors on May 12, 2007, for about ₹8.46 lakh, and cited faults such as a faulty speedometer and fuel leakage. Tata Motors, represented by advocate Anita Marathe, denied the allegations, saying the vehicle was inspected before delivery and complaints were handled under warranty. It argued the problems were minor or due to wear and tear. Wasan Motors also denied the allegations, saying the vehicle had been repaired to his satisfaction.
The commission noted that the surveyor could not conduct a road test or examine the internal mechanical condition, and that the inspection came years after the sale. It held that 2015 deterioration could not prove a defect in 2007, and that the complainant had not shown either company repaired improperly.
Key points
- The South Mumbai consumer commission dismissed a complaint against Tata Motors and its dealer, Wasan Motors.
- The complainant, Vilas Somo Pawar, alleged that his Tata Indigo XL developed repeated defects after he bought it in 2007.
- The commission said repeated repairs did not automatically prove a manufacturing defect from the time of sale.
- The commission also rejected the demand for a replacement vehicle or refund of the purchase price.
Coverage from
This story was put together automatically from the sources above. Open a source to read its original report. How nuze makes stories