National

Patna High Court stays Rs 3 lakh pension recovery from woman over officials' errors

· 1 source · Bihar edition

This story has no audio yet

The Patna High Court has halted a recovery order exceeding Rs 3 lakh against Reena Kumari, who receives a family pension. The order came from the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs (CBITC). Justice Purnendu Singh, sitting as a single bench, heard her writ petition on Wednesday and found that pensioners should not bear the cost of mistakes officials make in working out their pension.

According to the petition, the department on June 8, 2026 ordered Rs 6,000 to be deducted monthly over 56 instalments, over pension it said had been overpaid between February 2023 and April 2026. Her lawyer contended that this breached a DoPT office memorandum dated March 2, 2016, and that she had played no part in the excess payment, with no fraud or misrepresentation on her side. He also alleged that officials had made her sign blank papers under threat of stopping her pension, and then treated those signatures as her agreement to the recovery.

The court voiced concern at such coercive conduct and asked the concerned authorities to respond. It also told them to examine her representation seeking a recalculation of the disputed arrears and to decide the matter afresh within the law. The case will next be heard on December 15, 2026.

Key points

  • The Patna High Court stayed a recovery of over Rs 3 lakh from a family pensioner, Reena Kumari.
  • The court held that a pensioner cannot be penalised for errors in pension calculation by authorities.
  • The department ordered Rs 6,000 monthly deductions over 56 instalments, citing excess pension paid from February 2023 to April 2026.
  • Her counsel alleged the recovery breached a 2016 DoPT memorandum and that her signatures were obtained on blank papers under threat.
  • The court directed authorities to reconsider her representation, and the matter will be heard on December 15, 2026.

Coverage from

Topics

This story was put together automatically from the sources above. Open a source to read its original report. How nuze makes stories