National

Supreme Court cites colonial-era judge's sons case while ruling on family bias

· 1 source · Bihar edition

This story has no audio yet

The Supreme Court recalled a colonial-era episode in which Justice Badruddin Tyabji of the Bombay High Court let his two sons, both practising lawyers, appear before him despite concerns over conflict of interest. When Chief Justice Sir Lawrence Jenkins raised the matter, Justice Tyabji reportedly told him to mind his own business. The court drew on an article by Dr Balram K Gupta and the autobiography of Fali S Nariman.

A bench of Justices Manoj Misra and Manmohan cited the episode while hearing an appeal against the termination of an Assistant Teacher. The bench said the law has since developed, so close family ties can be grounds for disqualification where they create a reasonable likelihood of bias, and actual bias need not be proven. It held that an immediate blood relative of a person initiating disciplinary proceedings cannot adjudicate them, calling this a constitutional requirement under Article 14.

The court found that the inquiry committee convenor was the brother of the school secretary, who was the complainant, prosecutor and principal witness. The secretary was the sole witness on 11 of the 20 charges against the teacher.

Key points

  • The Supreme Court cited a colonial-era case in which a Bombay High Court judge let his sons appear before him.
  • Justice Badruddin Tyabji reportedly told the Chief Justice to mind his own business when questioned about it.
  • A bench of Justices Manoj Misra and Manmohan said close family ties can create a reasonable likelihood of bias.
  • The court found the inquiry convenor was the brother of the school secretary who had complained against an Assistant Teacher.
  • The secretary was the sole witness on 11 of the 20 charges against the teacher.

Coverage from

This story was put together automatically from the sources above. Open a source to read its original report. How nuze makes stories