National
Tripura official faces Rs 25,000 fine over denied RTI on Chakma customary law
Chief Information Commissioner Binoy Shankar Mishra has issued show-cause notices to S. Prabhu, then Additional Secretary of the Tribal Welfare Department, in an order made public on the day of reporting. The appeal was filed by Jagdish Rawat of the Chakma Development Foundation of India. The notices ask why disciplinary action should not follow over the denial of information on the Chakma Customary Laws Act, 2022.
Rawat had applied on 28 August 2023 for communications about the Act and certified copies of it. Prabhu, acting as public information officer and then first appellate authority, refused the information on the ground that the matter was pending before the State Legislature, a claim Rawat called false. He also forwarded the application to a private NGO, Chakma Miley Jodha. The commission held that this transfer was legally unsustainable.
The commission found that Prabhu reviewed his own decisions, contrary to a 2011 Delhi High Court judgment, and that he knowingly gave incorrect, incomplete and misleading information. It noted a delay of 1,131 days, which would have meant Rs 2,82,750 at Rs 250 a day, but the RTI Act caps the penalty at Rs 25,000.
Key points
- The commission imposed the maximum penalty of Rs 25,000 and issued show-cause notices to S. Prabhu.
- Prabhu reportedly refused the information on the ground that the matter was pending before the State Legislature, which Rawat called false.
- The commission held that forwarding the RTI application to Chakma Miley Jodha was legally unsustainable.
- The commission found that Prabhu reviewed his own decisions, contrary to a 2011 Delhi High Court judgment.
- The commission noted a delay of 1,131 days, but the RTI Act caps the total penalty at Rs 25,000.
Coverage from
Topics
This story was put together automatically from the sources above. Open a source to read its original report. How nuze makes stories